[discuss] Two accountability questions - help pls- Workshop 23 - ICANN accountability

Sun Aug 31 16:52:51 UTC 2014

Mike, perhaps you could go into more detail on this statement...

"As (it) is assuming that the greater "family" would cooperate with an IANA
change they viewed as not in the best interests of the Internet." 

For example giving some further definition of who/what is meant by the
"greater (Internet?) family", "cooperation" (or not?) with an IANA change,
and "best interests of the Internet".

Thanks,

M

-----Original Message-----
From: discuss-bounces at 1net.org [mailto:discuss-bounces at 1net.org] On Behalf
Of Mike Roberts
Sent: Sunday, August 31, 2014 9:37 AM
To: Jordan Carter
Cc: isoc-advisory-council at elists.isoc.org; 1Net List; ig at aptld.org;
Ianaxfer at Elists. Isoc. Org; ccnso-igrg at icann.org
Subject: Re: [discuss] Two accountability questions - help pls- Workshop 23
- ICANN accountability

I agree with Bill's comments.

I would also point out that focusing on IANA is like looking at an iceberg.
IANA, meaning the functions its staff carry out, is part of a global family
of technical and operational folks who make the DNS name resolution system
work.   Assuming that a change in the chain of command/accountability for
IANA will solve some perceivecd problem or set of problems is exceedingly
short sighted.  As is assuming that the greater "family" would cooperate
with an IANA change they viewed as not in the best interests of the
Internet.

- Mike

On Aug 31, 2014, at 8:00 AM, Jordan Carter <
<mailto:jordan at internetnz.net.nz> jordan at internetnz.net.nz> wrote:

> Dear all

> 

> Apologies for cross-posting...

> 

> I am seeking some community feedback as part of prepping for the 

> workshop on ICANN accountability scheduled for Wednesday 9am here at 

> #igf2014.

> 

> The particular questions I have, two, are:

> 

> 1. Is ICANN's accountability a subject for the whole Internet 

> community to resolve, or (as suggested by ICANN, in distinction from 

> the iana stewardship transition) an internal ICANN community matter?

> 

> 2. Can *internal* accountability arrangements, of whatever sort, ever 

> be adequate for an entity like ICANN that is intended (at least it 

> looks like that is ICANN's intention) to be responsible for the 

> stewardship of the iana functions?

> 

> 

> My view is that for the first, the clear answer is the broader 

> community; for the second, most of the discussions in the ICANN 

> community to date have been focused on internal arrangements except 

> for the weird ban on discussion internal structural accountability 

> measures.

> 

> I'd value any discussion on these to help inform the panel's work on
Wednesday.

> 

> Thanks,

> Jordan

> 

> Ps - InternetNZ is the designated manager of the .nz ccTLD; it has a 

> wider cause (a better world through a better Internet (which is an 

> open and uncaptured Internet)) and so is in an interesting situation 

> straddling parts of the Internet's technical and civil society 

> communities.

> 

> 

> PPS - The session description is as follows:

> 

> Discussion of how accountability goals are achieved at ICANN under its 

> multi-stakeholder governance processes. To whom is ICANN accountable 

> and what are the mechanisms for ensuring that accountability is 

> adequate? In what way do these mechanisms need strengthening or 

> further improvements, particularly in light of NTIA's announcement to 

> transition out its current role? How do checks and balances on power, 

> such as structural separation of key DNS operations encourage 

> accountability? How have ICANN's Affirmation of Commitments and the 

> Accountability and Transparency Review Team fostered (or undermined) 

> accountability goals at ICANN? What lessens were learned from the AoC 

> and ATRT processes on achieving accountability under a 

> multi-stakeholder governance regime? What is the role of ICANN's 

> Ombudsman Office in achieving accountability for the institution?

> 

> --

> Jordan Carter

> Chief Executive, InternetNZ

> 

> +64 21 442 649

> 

> twitter.com/jordantcarter

> 

> 'Hope is the dream of a person awake' -- French proverb

> 

> _______________________________________________

> discuss mailing list

>  <mailto:discuss at 1net.org> discuss at 1net.org

>  <http://1net-mail.1net.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss>
http://1net-mail.1net.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss

_______________________________________________

discuss mailing list

 <mailto:discuss at 1net.org> discuss at 1net.org

 <http://1net-mail.1net.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss>
http://1net-mail.1net.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://1net-mail.1net.org/pipermail/discuss/attachments/20140831/1bc43350/attachment-0001.html>